The Strategic Edge of Contract-to-Hire: A Guide for Hiring Managers


Hiring managers are continually seeking innovative strategies to attract and assess top talent. One approach gaining traction for its multifaceted benefits is the contract-to-hire model. This hiring strategy not only enhances the recruitment process but also offers a unique opportunity to evaluate candidates in real job scenarios. The essence of contract-to-hire and its advantages for both employers and job seekers are explored in the HireJar blog, “The Benefits of Contract-to-Hire: A Win-Win Approach for Job Seekers and Employers.”

Evaluating Candidate’s Abilities in Real-Time

The contract-to-hire model allows hiring managers to observe a candidate’s performance in the actual work environment. This hands-on assessment is invaluable, providing insights that go beyond the capabilities demonstrated in interviews or on resumes. It enables managers to gauge a candidate’s problem-solving skills, adaptability, and proficiency in real-time tasks, offering a comprehensive view of their potential impact on the company.

Cultural Fit and Reduced Hiring Risks

Another significant advantage of contract-to-hire is the ability to assess whether a candidate is a good cultural fit for the organization. Traditional hiring methods often rely on gut feelings during interviews and the subjective opinions of references, which can be inherently biased. The contract-to-hire model reduces these risks by allowing both the employer and the candidate to mutually evaluate compatibility over the contract period. This period serves as a practical trial, ensuring that both parties can make informed decisions about long-term employment.

Seamless Transition and Business Continuity

Candidates on a contract-to-hire basis can seamlessly transition into permanent roles, minimizing disruptions to business operations. This smooth transition ensures that once a candidate is deemed a good fit, they can continue contributing to the company without the need for a new onboarding process. It also provides candidates with a clear path to permanency, enhancing their engagement and commitment to the company’s goals.

Ideal Roles for Contract-to-Hire

Not all positions are suitable for the contract-to-hire model, but certain roles stand out as particularly well-suited. These include:

  • Technical and IT Positions: Roles such as software developers, system analysts, and IT support specialists are ideal for contract-to-hire. This model allows for the direct assessment of a candidate’s ability to adapt and excel in technical tasks.
  • Creative and Design Roles: For positions like graphic designers and UX/UI designers, contract-to-hire offers a chance to evaluate how a candidate’s creative vision aligns with the company’s needs.
  • Sales and Business Development: Particularly those with short sales cycles, where immediate performance can be a critical assessment factor.
  • Roles Requiring a Good Cultural Fit: Some positions necessitate a strong alignment with company culture, making the trial period of contract-to-hire invaluable.
  • High Turnover Roles: Positions in hospitality, customer service, and retail, which traditionally see high turnover rates, can benefit from the evaluative nature of contract-to-hire.

According to an analysis by HireJar, 27% of jobs posted on LinkedIn fall into categories ideally suited for contract-to-hire, yet less than 5% are advertised as contract positions. This discrepancy highlights an untapped potential for leveraging contract-to-hire to find the best candidates.

Addressing the Concern of Attracting Currently Employed Candidates

A common hesitation among companies is that advertising positions as contract-to-hire might deter candidates who are currently employed, due to the perceived instability compared to permanent roles. A strategic solution to this challenge is dual listing: advertising the job as a permanent role on the company website and certain job boards, while also posting it as a contract-to-hire position on platforms like HireJar. This approach can attract a broader range of candidates, including those who value the opportunity to prove their capabilities and fit within an organization before committing long-term.


The contract-to-hire model presents a strategic advantage for hiring managers looking to optimize their recruitment process. By allowing for an on-the-job evaluation of candidates, reducing hiring risks, and ensuring a seamless transition for suitable candidates, this approach aligns the interests of both employers and job seekers. Moreover, by adopting a flexible listing strategy, companies can attract a diverse pool of talent, including those currently employed who are seeking a secure pathway to a permanent role. As the job market evolves, contract-to-hire stands out as a pragmatic and effective method to secure the right talent for the right positions, ensuring mutual success for employers and employees alike.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *